Just saw a letter in the Straits Times Forum page entitled “Time
ripe for a pan-Asian university,” which argues that in light of the blame game for
the “Covid-19” and growing anti-Chinese sentiment (which affects non-China
Chinese) in the West, it was time for Asians to produce a “Pan-Asian University.”
The letter can be found at:
This letter also reminded me of a talk I attended that was
conducted by Her Excellency, Ms. Kara Owen, the High Commissioner of the United
Kingdom, a few months ago (back in the pre-Circuit Breaker days). In that talk,
the High Commissioner acknowledged that Singapore had sent many students to the
UK and said that she hoped that there would be more student interaction
between the UK and Singapore with more UK students heading to study in
Singapore.
Interestingly enough, the topic of universities is one of the
classic cases of Westerners having more confidence in the future of Asia than
Asians. I remember telling someone of South Asian decent what the British High
Commissioner had said and his only reaction was “She must be mad, why would they
want to come here when they have the best universities there.” This reaction is,
sadly, not a lone one. As far as most Asians are concerned, the world’s best
education remains Western.
To an extent, this is true. If you look at rankings of the
world’s best universities, they are, with the exception of Oxford and Cambridge,
inevitably American. A look at the Times Higher Education Ranking can be found
at:
These rankings are pretty entrenched and if you look at the
normal Asian mindset, unlikely to change anytime soon. I look at Singapore as
the prime example. We invest heavily in education. We are proud of our universities
and we spend a lot of money on them. Yet, despite all our pride in our home-grown
universities, our country is inevitably run by people who went to Oxbridge for
a first degree and did an MBA in an American University.
There are of course, reasons for the dominance of Western Universities
in the top ranks of the world’s best. For all the apparent issues with Western
societies (think social unrest on American streets at the moment), they remain
societies that are open to free expression and more importantly the free flow
of ideas. America in particular has rolled out the welcome mat for the world’s
best brains and allowed them to flourish. Furthermore, as in the case of
America, there is a culture that encourages experimentation. Part of that
culture includes a tolerance for failure, which remains an anathema to many
Asian societies
For many Asian governments, there is also prestige in having
people trained by the world’s best. Here in Singapore, we take pride in the
fact that our top people have not just proven themselves at home but in world-renown
places like Harvard, Cambridge and so on. Governments in places like China have
also done the same.
Having said all that, the question remains – why can’t Asia
produce a world-class university and why can’t we accept the idea that people
from the West might want to come to study in this part of the world.
The economics are certainly making Asia a more attractive
place to be. For all it’s faults, China is the world’s second largest and most
dynamic economy and other Asian countries are also following suite. Business
interest in the West has certainly become more focused on Asia. I remember, when
Ogilvy hired Tham Khai Meng as its global creative head. While the local media
made a song and dance about the first Singaporean to be a global creative head
of a major ad agency, there was also another person who got promoted, which was
Miles Young, who became CEO. Mr. Young cut his teeth in Asia-Pacific.
A major ad agency thought it was important to fill its key
positions with people with Asian experience because it saw that this was where
the future consumers would be. However, are Asians being more than just copycats
of a Western Mind?
Developing a great university would be the right start to proving
that the answer is no. There are positive signs. I think of John Chambers,
former CEO of Cisco Systems singing the praise of the Indian Institutes of
Technology (IIT). I think of the efforts of Singapore’s Universities to create
a start up system in the same way that Stanford did around Silicon Valley (as a
matter of disclosure, I am working for NTU’s start up and commercialization arm
and I have worked for the IIT Alumni).
However, more needs to b done. Asian societies will need to
encourage greater innovation, which means a culture that allows experimentation,
failure and questioning of established rules. The money is there to spend on
research but cultures need to match. Think of the King Abdullah University of
Science and Technology (KAUST), which has the full financial backing of Saudi
Aramco, the world’s most profitable company. The facilities are wonderful and
its hired famous names but has the culture created innovation and great
research?
Admittedly, I didn’t shine in university but if you look at
what universities do, you’ll see that they are the bedrock of producing an
innovative and prosperous economy. America has ruled the world in just about
every sphere. It has most of the world’s best research universities. Surely that
cannot be a coincidence. Instead of sending students there, most Asian governments
could do well to ask what makes American universities so good and to replicate
it within. There’s no reason why there can’t be a great Asian university.
No comments
Post a Comment