Thursday, June 25, 2020

Nobody in The World Does it Like That – Nobody in the World Has Problems Like Ours


One of my favourite movies is a Bollywood flick called 3 Idiots, which tells the story of three college friends. One them turns out to be a brilliant mind called Phunsukh Wangdu, who invents a host of gadgets in a remote part of India. Not only did this movie made me laugh throughout, it also gave me a sense of happiness to see the simple Mr. Wangdu coming up triumphant against someone who had become a corporate big shot.

It turns out that the character of Phunsukh Wangdu was based on a real person, an inventor called Sonam Wangchuk, who is from the Ladakh, the Indian State which shares a border with Tibet. Mr. Wangchuk has essentially become famous for building a campus run entirely on renewable energy and a technique of storing fresh water using artificial glaciers. More on Mr. Wangchuk and his inventions can be found at:


Mr. Wangchuk is what I’d call one of the best things to emerge in the science of development. He’s a local innovator, who creates solutions that are unique to a particular region. If you look at Mr. Wangchuk’s two key inventions, you will notice that they were perfect for the Himalayan region. Who else but someone who grew up in that part of the world could have come up with solutions for the issues faced by that part of the world?

While I believe that globalization has on balance been a positive force, there has been one major flaw. It’s worked on the assumption that what is good for the Western (mainly American) world has been good for the developing world. This has been clearly seen in business where global business has come to mean American multinationals and it’s also happened in the area of development – one only has to visit any given developing country to witness the number of “development” agents from Western NGOs hanging around.

This is not a bad thing in as much as both multinationals and NGOs do provide capital and training for the local population. I think of Singapore, a small island that has managed to achieve economic maturity within a generation. Part of our success has been due to the fact that our economy is built by multinationals and our people and businesses are placed in a situation where “best in Singapore” is not acceptable – you have to be best in the world.

There is however, one problem. When you get solutions from elsewhere, they don’t always in the local context and finding a solution to the solution ends up becoming a very expensive process for all parties involved. Business is many examples of how failing to take into account of the local context has failed. Ford forgot that locals in South America are Spanish speaking rather than English speaking. Hence, the launch of the Ford Nova was a failure. Who wants to buy a car called “No Go” (direct translation of Nova from Spanish). Closer to home, international burger chains found themselves getting beating in the Philippines because they didn’t adapt to local taste and got a kicking by the local player, Jollibee.

When this happens in business, its merely a case of the business failing to make the money they hopped they’d make. It’s a little more serious when it comes to development agencies and NGOs. When the foreign solution fails, the development agencies and NGOs ask for and get more money. However, the locals don’t see their lives improving. Hence, the common criticism of development agencies being that they only develop the employees of the development agencies.

Home grown solutions provided by the likes of Mr. Wangchuk tend to be more effective in the goal of helping the local community. The reason is simple, they understand the local context such as what the local communities will accept, the local geography and the available resources. I read an interview by Mr. Wangchuk who argued that his home province of Ladakh did not need the industrialization as the rest of India. The interview can be found at:


Once again, I am by no means rejecting the role of the outside world in developing and creating prosperity. It’s vital for the world to be interconnected if it prospers. However, the most effective solutions cannot be imposed on a community because they worked elsewhere. The cost-effective ones are inevitably developed from the ground up by the people who understand the ground and aided by people with the skills to execute no matter where they come from.

My nation of Singapore has been thus far successful with imported solutions. However, we’re discovering that as the economy matures, we need a different way of solving problems. How do we do that? The answer is clearly to look to the people who understand what’s going on.

It will take time for a culture of encouraging home-grown innovation to develop, especially when the old method of importing solutions worked so well. I think of a local inventor who once developed something for our water utility. The civil servants told him, “Nobody else in the world does it the way you’ve proposed.” His reply was “Nobody else in the world has water issues like ours.” This is an answer that we need to apply to the way we do things if we are to encourage the development of necessary home grown innovation.


No comments

© BeautifullyIncoherent
Maira Gall