Study What We Want You to Study
When I was still at school and ended up in discussions
on civilisations, I always felt that I needed to make the point to my English
friends that the Chinese were living in cities when Europeans were still living
in caves.
I think of this era of my life, because I’ve come to
appreciate that Chinese history is very instructive to the current geopolitical
situation. Whilst the Chinese were living in cities when the Europeans were
living in caves, the Chinese also pioneered two of the worst sins of modern geopolitics
– namely protectionism and intellectual arrogance. Sure, we started living in
cities but 1500AD, protectionism and intellectual arrogance made China so
stagnant that the people who were dwelling in caves when the Chinese lived
cities, ended up pointing guns at them and the Chinese could only offer spears
and wooden shields.
I blame two people for this. One is Confucius, the
original bureaucrat who was obsessed with going back to a “golden age” that
never existed. Thanks to him, the entire Chinese system was based on going back
to a mythical golden age and nobody thought of shaping the future. The other
person who is responsible is the first emperor, Qin Shi Huang who built the “Great
Wall,” which cost dearly in lives and treasure. The Great Wall is a tourist
attraction and we love to go on and on about how its only thing you can see
from the moon. The truth is the “Great Wall” was a failure. The “Barbarians”
inevitably found a way in.
The Qin emperor didn’t just build a physical wall. He
built walls in generations of Chinese. As far as he was concerned, people would
only know what he wanted them to know and he proceeded to burn books that he
didn’t approve of on a regular basis. So, whilst China and Chinese history is
filled with intellectual treasures, its also filled with so much more that
could have been.
I start with this monologue, because if you look at what’s
going on in the world, you’ll notice that these things from Chinese history are
taking place in front of us. Ironically, its not so much the Chinese exhibiting
these traits but the nation that was the anti-thesis of these values – America.
Many people have described the current president as
trying to be like a “King” of 18th century Europe. However, he seems
more like a Chinese Emperor. Look at what he was bragging about in his first
term – building a wall. As an ethnic Chinese, this sounds strangely familiar.
Now, in his second term, he’s on a mission to continue
being like a Chinese Emperor. He wants to build walls of the mind. America,
which has spent centuries being a free market of ideas, now has school boards
talking about banning certain books.
This on its own wouldn’t be so bad if he wasn’t on a
mission to make it worse by going on a war against America’s Universities,
insisting that they teach an approved “non-woke” agenda. At the time of
writing, Mr. Trump has frozen all federal funding to Harvard University, one of
America’s most prominent universities, for refusing to comply with his orders:
https://www.ft.com/content/5c8bca38-8e6d-4df1-bbb1-d84e0b2a5962
Given that Harvard has an exceedingly large endowment fund, one might argue that there’s no reason for them to receive federal funding. However, the issue is not so much the funding but the “interference” from the government and the government’s insistence that it has control over what universities teach. Mr. Trump is essentially arguing that the government needs to step in to stop the universities from teaching a “woke” agenda but whose to say what exactly is “woke” and who is to say that this won’t be used to interfere with the teaching of what the government doesn’t want to be taught, which is, given Mr. Trump’s reaction to medical advice dispensed during Covid, a real possibility.
If you look at what makes America such a dominant
player in so many fields, you’ll find that America has inevitably done it
through an ability to nurture the best brains into innovative and entrepreneurial
ones. America has done this primarily through its universities. It is no coincidence
that Silicon Valley, the place that has minted billionaires is centred around
Stanford University.
If you look at the top ten universities in the world, you’ll
find that only Oxford, Cambridge and Imperial College London are not American.
What does this mean? It simply means that America has the best places to
nurture the best minds. America doesn’t just nurture its own. It encourages
people from the rest of the world to attend American Universities and then work
and even become entrepreneurs, creating jobs and other forms of wealth in America:
https://www.timeshighereducation.com/world-university-rankings/latest/world-ranking
Yet, while he’s talking about making America Great
Again, he’s going after the very things that make America great. Like it or
not, hot beds of innovation and creativity don’t toe the line of dictation from
the government.
Sure, China is a communist dictatorship and a highly effective
police state. However, it’s a place that has understood that “Greatness” comes
from an ability to innovate and create. It’s also learnt the lesson from
history that it needs the global community to stay reasonably prosperous. So,
when Mr. Trump was rounding up people he didn’t like, the Chinese were opening
up to people with the ability to do work.
How it is possible for America to win with Mr. Trump at
the helm. He’s trying to compete in the low-end stuff, where China has a clear
advantage. Yet at the same time, he’s going out of his way to harm the pillars
that make America a world leader in high tech and high value stuff. Instead of
making friends, he’s alienating the ones he has. By contrast, the Chinese are
keeping their edge in the low value stuff, investing in the high edge stuff and
going out of their way to befriend the people Mr. Trump is screwing over.
China got lucky in that it was an ancient civilization
and it didn’t feel the negative effects of its arrogance and isolationism for
centuries. The world was simply not connected back then. So, the receipts of arrogance
took a while to come in.
This is not the case for modern America under Trump.
Our technologies have reduced the time it took to do things in the past by many
folds. Any loss suffered will be a result of allowing the same arrogance and
isolationism that brought down and ancient civilisation.