The Story of Unpaid Wages – Copyright – Daily Post
Nigeria
I had the opportunity to catch with one my oldest
friends, after a day of looking through boxes of various old cases in the warehouse.
During our catch-up session, we found that we had a number of common worries, which
are rooted in the fact that we are both approaching 50, our earning power is on
the slippery slope down and its unlikely that we’ll reach the stage where we’ll
ever be able to look to our dependents to take care of us in old age. My friend
then made the point to me that whilst things are likely to look very bleak for
the rest of us, I was in the lucky position of being in an industry that is
likely to do well.
This got me thinking about the prospects that I and
many of my contemporaries are likely to face as economies (as the economies that
people rather than statistics operate in) around the world lose the government support.
In a way, I was lucky that I never “climbed” very high and thus don’t have that
far to fall. I will probably struggle to survive like the masses. However, for
those who have gotten onto the “Five C” ladder, things could be rather
different. So, its perhaps a good time think of the awful scenario of the very
real possibility of being thrown out of work.
Let’s start with the good news. If one is thrown out
of work because the employer goes bankrupt, your salary is considered a “Preferential
Debt.” When a company goes under, there is a pecking order as to who gets paid.
The way this works is that when a company goes under, a liquidator will step
in. The liquidator’s job is to “realise” what’s left of the business (collected
debts and sold off whatever assets can be sold off). The first thing that gets
paid is the “expenses of the liquidation” which includes the liquidator’s
professional fees. After that, if there’s money left, salaries will have to be
paid, followed by CPF and the various taxes. If there’s any money left after
that, the “unsecured” creditors get paid.
There is, however, a cap of S$12,500 on preferential
payments. So, if you’re a waiter who is owed a month’s salary, you’re in luck.
Chances are your salary will be paid. However, if you’re a General Manager on S$18,000
a month, only S$12,500 will be preferred. The remaining S$5,500 will be “unsecured.”
You should also be aware that only the “salary” is preferred. Leave-pay, notice-pay,
medical claims and whatever allowances are not “preferred.”
To qualify for any dividend from a liquidation, you
need to fill out what is called a “Proof of Debt” form in order to be counted
as a creditor. It also helps to know what’s going on in the liquidation
process. So, where possible, try to attend the creditor’s meeting and keep in
touch with the liquidation staff, especially when the topic of their payment
comes around. Scrutinize to ensure that their bills are not inflated.
You should take note that liquidation is a legal
process, which inevitably means that it is time consuming. Any potential
payouts are likely to happen not faster than six-months after the company goes
into liquidation. Do not depend on payouts from a liquidation scenario to pay
your bills.
That’s the good news in the event that you lose your
job due to your employer going insolvent. As any medical practitioner will tell
you:
The key message is that one should always be aware of
what’s happening in the employer’s business for the simple reason that one’s own
income is dependent on the boss’s business.
The first step is to adapt the mindset that loyalty
has its limits. A good businessman is always on the look out to create greater
efficiencies and more importantly cost savings. You are not exempted from that.
The boss will replace you with someone cheaper or a machine that merely needs a
bit of oil and can-do things at a push of a button. The process used to be
limited to blue-collar manufacturing jobs. Now, in the age of Artificial
Intelligence (AI) and block chain, many white-collar jobs are being replaced by
machines.
This mindset protects you from the fantasy that the
boss will always be there to protect you. One should always save for a rainy
day and one should have a side-hustle, whether it’s a part-time job or find
ways to make a hobby pay (I used to wait tables, until Covid put a dent in the
restaurant business and I do encourage people to support the advertisers of this
blog and I take YouGov Surveys).
The second point is that you need to be observant
about the health of the business and the boss’s reaction to his or her
circumstances. If the boss has an attitude thinks has the mindset that the
supplier is getting “ya-ya” and expects the supplier to negotiate for lower prices
to get what is due to them – you better start preparing to upscale your alternative
income and ensure that your rate of sending out CVs gets higher, because chances
are they’ll treat not paying your salary in the same manner if they’re pushed
into it.
However, while “bad boss’s” make headlines in issues
of “non-payment,” the truth is that its actually the nice guys who screw up
their employees in issues of “non-payment.” Being a good person and even a good
businessman does not exempt you from making bad business decisions.
One of the saddest cases I had to handle involved a
construction company that hadn’t paid its workers for five months. The boss was
actually a good man (took construction workers on holiday with him) and had done
great things for his company (they did big projects). However, he ran into a
spell of bad luck and decided to throw all his eggs into a “big-kill” project.
However, the usual story of slow payments down the line happened and he couldn’t
sustain it. His staff from the admin down to the workers gave their all and
worked for him without pay for five months. He took personal sacrifices to do
what the right thing by his workers. Sold his private property and his BMW so that
the workers could get something. In the end, it still wasn’t enough and we had
to move in despite his best efforts to save his business. He was put into
personal bankruptcy thanks to a ruthless labor supplier and sorting out the wage
bill was not funny (I broke professional rules to help a few of the guys out).
He was a good guy and his intentions were good. He was
by all intents an inspiring leader (as my boss pointed out – the workers were
quite happy to take photos with him despite not being paid for over five
months). However, he broke the cardinal rule of business – he ran out of money.
Your bills will not stop pilling up just because your
boss is running for sainthood. If your boss misses one month’s salary, it
should be a sign that he or she is not going to be able to pay the month after
that. Now, this is not a hard and fast rule. There are situations where the
boss had a bad month and the next month proved to be significantly better. You
might want to stay for another month, especially if you see your boss has sold
his home to ensure that you can keep yours.
However, the reality is that businesses do go through
rough patches and a good majority do not recover. Even if you decide to give
two months of free work, you should leave by the third if you see that you’re
not going to get paid. Your bills don’t stop just because your employer is
going through a rough patch.
Ignore the rosy statistics. Governments are now
pulling back support and many businesses will go under. One needs to be ready
for the awful eventuality that your employer might be one of them.
No comments
Post a Comment